Next Manchester United Manager Odds: Howe Favourite as Pressure Builds on Carrick

Author Imageby Leon Marshall

9 minutes read /

The image shows the logo of the Premier League football club Manchester United displayed prominently. The Manchester United logo is on the left side, featuring a red and gold shield with intricate designs including a ship at the top, a devil holding a trident in the center, and two footballs on either side. The words "Manchester" and "United" are written in a circular design around the shield. To the right of the logo, there is the silhouette of a person viewed from the back, standing in what appears to be a football pitch or a stadium setting, illuminated by bright stadium lights. The person's details are not visible, creating a mysterious and intense atmosphere.

Manchester United insist they are not looking for a manager, but the bookmakers now make Michael Carrick odds-on to be the first Premier League boss out of a job this season. A 4-1 Champions League defeat at Como on 21 October stretched United’s winless run to seven games in all competitions, the club’s worst sequence since Louis van Gaal’s final season, and the next manager market has Eddie Howe and Antonio Conte sharing favouritism at 2/1.

With betting sites reacting to every result at Old Trafford, the market has shifted quickly since August. United opened the season with a 2-0 defeat at newly promoted Hull, thrashed Ipswich 5-2 with a Bruno Fernandes hat-trick, then drew 2-2 at Everton after conceding late and lost 1-0 at home to a ten-man Manchester City. A 1-1 draw at Fulham on 20 September was followed by a 3-2 Carabao Cup exit to Brighton from 2-0 up, a 1-1 home draw with ten-man Tottenham that was booed off, a 2-0 defeat at Atletico Madrid and another 1-1 draw at Leeds on 18 October.

That leaves United 13th with seven points from seven league games, their worst start to a league season since 1986, and already 14 points behind leaders Manchester City. The Como result turned a slow start into a crisis. Nico Paz scored after two minutes and again after the break, Tasos Douvikas and Ramon added the third and fourth, and Joshua Zirkzee’s stoppage-time goal was the only reply. Carrick called the performance “not acceptable” and admitted he was angry, but asked whether he would walk away he said: “No. It’s not about me right now.”

Next Manchester United Manager Odds
Manager Odds Recommended Betting Site Secure Link
Eddie Howe 2/1 BetVictor Visit Site
Antonio Conte 2/1 BetVictor Visit Site
Julian Nagelsmann 3/1 BetVictor Visit Site
Fabian Hurzeler 4/1 BetVictor Visit Site
Kieran McKenna 6/1 BetVictor Visit Site
Thomas Tuchel 12/1 BetVictor Visit Site
Carlo Ancelotti 12/1 BetVictor Visit Site
Gareth Southgate 16/1 BetVictor Visit Site

*Odds correct as of 22 October 2026 and subject to change. Check with bookmakers for the latest prices.

Why Carrick Is Under Pressure

Carrick took over as interim boss in January, won 12 of his 17 games and took United from mid-table to third, which earned him a contract to 2028 in May. This season the same squad, strengthened by Carlos Baleba, Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans, has won two of 11 matches, and both of those came against newly promoted Ipswich and Azerbaijan’s Sabah. United have not kept a clean sheet, have been out-run in six of their seven league games and take more shots than anyone in the division while ranking joint-worst for quality of chance. Fernandes, whose chance creation has roughly halved since last season, has one goal involvement in his last nine games.

The pressure is no longer only external. Fernandes publicly questioned the decision not to press man-for-man at Como, and Lisandro Martinez said after the defeat in Madrid that he expected more from technical director Jason Wilcox over summer recruitment, adding that the club “can’t keep changing, changing, changing the manager”. United’s summer spend of £163m was less than Hull and Ipswich committed, and with Benjamin Sesko injured there is no recognised striker available. Carrick, for his part, says he does not need reassurance from the board and told reporters after Leeds: “I understand the situation doesn’t look great but I have no doubts we can go on a good run.”

The sack race market tells its own story. Carrick is 7/4 with Ladbrokes and Coral to be the next Premier League manager to leave, and most firms are shorter at 4/6. William Hill priced him at 33/1 for the same market on 15 August and now go 8/11. Crystal Palace’s Pierre Sage is second favourite at 9/2 after a 5-0 defeat to Brighton, with Fulham’s Alvaro Arbeloa next at 8/1. BoyleSports went 4/6 that Carrick leaves Old Trafford before the end of 2026, and that was before the Como game.

Eddie Howe (2/1) – The Available Option

Howe has been favourite since the market opened, and his price has barely moved, sitting between 15/8 and 9/4 since mid-September. He stepped down at Newcastle at the end of July after almost five years in charge, having delivered the club’s first major trophy in 70 years with the 2025 Carabao Cup and two Champions League qualifications. He said he needed time to recharge after a 12th-place finish last season, but journalist Dean Jones reports he would be keen on the job if it became available.

Pros:

  • No compensation and no notice period. Howe could be in the building within days, which matters enormously for a mid-season appointment.
  • He has already proven he can build a Champions League side in the Premier League from a difficult starting point, and his teams press with the intensity United have lacked.

Cons:

  • His final season at Newcastle was flat, and there are questions over whether he has the energy for the most scrutinised job in English football straight after a burnout break.
  • Howe has never managed a squad with this many big personalities, and his loyalty to a settled core did not always help Newcastle when results turned.

Antonio Conte (2/1) – The Proven Fixer

Conte is the big mover. BetVictor had him at 9/1 on 17 September and have cut him to 2/1, joint favourite with Howe, after reports that his representatives signalled interest in the job. Betfair, Sky Bet and Paddy Power still go 6/1, so the market is split. He left Napoli in May after a difficult season defending the Scudetto, which means he is available immediately, and his record of instant success at Chelsea, Inter and Napoli keeps him in the conversation whenever a big English job looks like opening up.

Pros:

  • Nobody in the market has a better record of turning an underperforming squad into title winners inside one season.
  • He is out of work, so there is no compensation to negotiate and no notice period, and his demanding approach would leave no room for the drift that has crept into United’s performances.

Cons:

  • Conte expects heavy backing in the transfer market and rarely stays beyond two seasons, which sits awkwardly with a hierarchy that talks about long-term stability.
  • His three-at-the-back system and short shelf life at clubs are the same concerns supporters had with Amorim.

Julian Nagelsmann (3/1) – The Free Agent

Nagelsmann left the Germany job in early July after a shock World Cup exit to Paraguay in the round of 32, and he has been waiting for the right club opportunity since. Still only 39, he is the most fashionable available name on the continent. BetVictor go 3/1, the rest of the market 4/1, and The Telegraph reports he is keen on the role.

Pros:

  • A modern, adaptable coach who has already handled a giant in Bayern Munich and won the Bundesliga there.
  • He is unattached, so there is no compensation to negotiate, and he is young enough to be a long-term appointment rather than a firefighter.

Cons:

  • His Bayern exit came amid reports of friction with senior players, and the German exit was messy too.
  • He has never worked in England and would be learning the Premier League while trying to rescue a season.

Fabian Hurzeler (4/1) – The Rising Coach

The Brighton head coach was 25/1 when this market opened and is now 4/1 with BetVictor and 6/1 elsewhere. He knocked United out of the Carabao Cup from 2-0 down, has since put five past Crystal Palace, and is viewed at Old Trafford as exactly the kind of young, progressive coach the ownership says it wants. The complication is that he signed a new Brighton contract in the summer, so he would be expensive to prise away.

Pros:

  • His Brighton side press and attack with the energy United have lacked all season, and he has done it on a fraction of the budget.
  • At 33 he could be a decade-long appointment rather than another short-term fix.

Cons:

  • Brighton would demand a large compensation fee, and the club has a history of refusing to sell its coaches cheaply.
  • He has never managed a dressing room with this many senior egos, and a mid-season move to a club in crisis is a very different job from building at Brighton.

Thomas Tuchel (12/1) – The Serial Winner

Tuchel has drifted from 7/2 to 12/1 with BetVictor and 14/1 elsewhere as the market has accepted that he is going nowhere. He took England to third place at the 2026 World Cup, their best finish since 1966, and has since signed an extension through to Euro 2028. That makes him an awkward fit for a mid-season club job, even allowing for his Champions League win with Chelsea and his history of instant impact.

Pros:

  • Few managers have a better record of walking into a big club mid-season and winning quickly, as he did at Chelsea in 2021.
  • He knows the Premier League, speaks the language of elite players and would not be intimidated by the size of the job.

Cons:

  • He is under contract with the FA until 2028, and walking out on England eighteen months before a home Euros would be a public relations disaster for everyone involved.
  • His club spells have tended to end in fallouts with hierarchies, which is exactly what United are trying to leave behind.

Carlo Ancelotti (12/1) – The Elder Statesman

Ancelotti took charge of Brazil for the 2026 World Cup and remains the most decorated manager on the board. He has won league titles in five countries and knows the Premier League from his time at Chelsea and Everton. BetVictor go 12/1, but Betfair, Sky Bet and Paddy Power are as big as 25/1.

Pros:

  • The ultimate dressing room manager, capable of handling superstar egos without public drama.
  • His calm would suit a club that has lurched from one crisis to the next since 2013.

Cons:

  • At 67 he is unlikely to be a long-term appointment, and United have said they want stability rather than another short-term fix.
  • His international commitments would need unwinding first.

Gareth Southgate (16/1) – The Culture Builder

The former England boss remains a prominent name in the conversation because of his ties with key figures in the United hierarchy, and every major firm has him at 16/1. He has been out of work since Euro 2024 and has repeatedly said he would only return for the right club project.

Pros:

  • Southgate is an expert at fixing a broken institutional culture and handling extreme media pressure.
  • His track record with young players would suit a squad that is increasingly built around academy graduates.

Cons:

  • He has not managed a club side since Middlesbrough in 2009.
  • Perceived as a conservative tactician, his appointment would face immediate pushback from a fanbase desperate for front-foot football.

Other Names in the Frame

While the top eight candidates are the current focus of the market, several other coaches are being monitored.

Kieran McKenna (6/1)

The former United coach is unattached after leaving Ipswich and has long been admired at Carrington. BetVictor make him 6/1, although Betfair, Sky Bet and Paddy Power go 14/1. He would be a popular, progressive choice, but his one season in the Premier League ended in relegation.

Cesc Fabregas (11/1)

The newest name on the list is the Como head coach who has just taken United apart. Fabregas was priced up at 11/1 by Betfair, Sky Bet and Paddy Power within hours of the 4-1 win, and his Arsenal and Chelsea playing career gives him an obvious Premier League profile. Como would not let him go cheaply mid-season.

Unai Emery (14/1)

The Aston Villa manager is 14/1 across the board. His European record speaks for itself, but prising him out of a settled project in Birmingham mid-season would be expensive and complicated.

Darren Fletcher (20/1)

Fletcher steadied the ship as interim after Amorim’s exit and is now coaching the under-18s. He remains the obvious internal option if the board needs a caretaker again, but a permanent appointment would be a gamble given his lack of senior experience.

Mauricio Pochettino and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer (16/1 and 25/1)

Solskjaer was the odds-on favourite when Amorim was sacked in January, but the club opted for Carrick and he has drifted to 25/1 everywhere. Pochettino, now in charge of the United States, is 16/1 with BetVictor and 25/1 elsewhere, another familiar name the market refuses to let go of.

What’s Next for Manchester United?

The official line has not changed. The board backed Carrick with a contract to 2028 five months ago, and TEAMtalk reports that the club is not currently planning an immediate change, with Wilcox still supportive. Reports elsewhere are less reassuring. The Touchline claims Carrick faces a high risk of dismissal if United fail to beat Bournemouth, that the board believes the players have lost faith in him, and that the club has already begun identifying replacements. INEOS would make any final decision, and the hierarchy is expected to discuss the manager’s position before the weekend.

The fixtures leave no hiding place. Bournemouth visit Old Trafford on Sunday 25 October, United travel to Chelsea on Saturday 31 October, Roma come to Manchester in the Champions League on Tuesday 3 November and Aston Villa follow on Sunday 8 November, the last game before the international break. A win on Sunday takes some heat out of both the sack race and the next manager market. Another defeat, and at 4/6 the bookmakers already think they know what happens next.